Speed follows temperature
Reaction time is not fixed across the day. One of the clearest links is with core body temperature, which runs on a daily rhythm: low in the early hours, rising through the day, high in the afternoon or evening depending on the person.
The hard part is separating temperature from everything else that changes over a day, such as how long you have been awake. In 2002, Wright, Hull and Czeisler used a forced desynchrony protocol on 14 volunteers. Their schedules were set to a day length that did not match 24 hours, so sleep times and the internal clock drifted apart and could be measured separately. Several measures were better when body temperature was elevated: working memory, alertness, visual attention, and the slowest tenth of reaction times. The effect held partly independently of internal clock time, which suggests temperature itself shapes how well the brain performs.
Larks and owls have different peaks
The rise does not arrive at the same clock time for everyone. In a 2014 study, Lara, Madrid and Correa tested morning types and evening types in both a morning and an evening session. Each group responded fastest at its own preferred time of day and slowest at the other. On a longer attention task, performance slipped steadily over time mainly at the wrong time of day: morning types declined in the evening session, evening types in the morning one.
A 2015 study of athletes by Facer-Childs and Brandstaetter at the University of Birmingham went a step further. The best predictor of when someone performed well was how long they had been awake, not the hour on the clock. Individual performance varied by as much as 26% over a single day. The authors argued against the common assumption that athletes simply perform best in the evening.
So when is your best hour
The evidence points to a personal curve rather than a shared one. For a typical person, reactions tend to be slower in the first hours after waking and quicker later, once body temperature is up. Where the peak falls depends on chronotype and on when you got up. An early riser and a late sleeper sitting at the same desk can be at opposite ends of their day at 9am, while the meeting invite treats them as one person.
The studies are small and use laboratory tasks, so they do not give a universal reaction-time timetable or prove that a particular hour is wrong for everyone. They do support a practical approach: measure rather than guess. A short reaction test at a few fixed times over a week gives a rough picture of your own pattern, which is more relevant than any average.