Looking for the source
The rule usually goes: eight glasses of eight ounces, every day, and coffee does not count. In 2002 Heinz Valtin, a physiologist at Dartmouth Medical School, tried to find the evidence for it. He searched databases and older literature and asked nutritionists who study thirst and fluid intake.
He found no scientific studies supporting it. Surveys of thousands of healthy adults suggested such large amounts were not needed, and he concluded that caffeinated drinks, and to a lesser extent moderate amounts of beer, can count towards daily fluid. The body’s own system for regulating water balance, he noted, does the job well.
His conclusion came with conditions. It applies to healthy adults in temperate climates who are not very active. People exercising hard, working in heat or managing certain illnesses can need more. Because a negative is hard to prove, Valtin ended by inviting readers to send him any study he had missed.
What official advice says now
Public health guidance has not abandoned the number so much as loosened it. The NHS suggests aiming for six to eight cups or glasses of fluid a day, calls this a guide, and says water, lower-fat milk and lower-sugar drinks, including tea and coffee, all count. It also notes that some fluid comes from food. So the eight glasses survive, as an upper estimate that includes the kettle.
Does a little dehydration matter
It can, in some ways. Two controlled studies from the same research group looked at mild dehydration, about 1.4 to 1.6% of body weight, brought on by exercise, in some sessions with a diuretic as well.
In 26 young men, mild dehydration increased errors on a visual vigilance task, slowed responses on a working memory task, and raised fatigue and tension. In 25 young women, most measures of thinking were not affected. What changed was how they felt: worse mood, more fatigue, more headache, and tasks that seemed harder and concentration that felt lower.
These were young volunteers made deliberately dehydrated through exercise in a laboratory. The studies show that small fluid deficits can affect mood and some kinds of attention. They do not show that an office worker who drinks five glasses rather than eight is impaired.
The useful version
For most healthy adults, drinking when thirsty, with more in heat or during exercise, is consistent with the evidence. A glass on the desk makes it easier to notice when you have not had any for a while. People with heart or kidney conditions, or who have been told to limit or increase fluids, should follow their own medical advice instead.