The number was an identity
An ICQ number was an account identifier, usually called a UIN. Adium’s ICQ documentation describes that numeric identity, while listing several expansions of the initials. The useful distinction is between the number identifying the account and the name a person might display beside it.
ICQ was released by Mirabilis in 1996. Its account model meant that giving someone a number was a way to identify the account they should contact. A short number took less space to pass around, and a memorable pattern could distinguish it from an ordinary string of digits. That is a practical attraction, not evidence of a special technical privilege.
What the client actually used
The mICQ command-line client makes the separation visible. Its login options have one argument for the UIN and another for the password. The number identifies the account; it is not the secret that authenticates its owner. On first startup, the program asks for an existing UIN or offers to create an account, then imports the server contact list after login.
Its interactive manual also distinguishes UINs from nicknames when describing contacts. Users can refer to people through either, and the client has commands for changing a contact’s local nickname. A convenient label in one person’s address book is therefore not the same thing as a new account identity.
A market, with a place and a date
In a 2010 report, WIRED contributor Alexey Kovalev described Russian trading in short ICQ numbers. Repeated digits could increase a number’s appeal. His examples document a particular market; they do not establish a universal price for every UIN.
The value was attached to the identity people wanted to own and show, rather than a different messaging feature unlocked by fewer digits. A desirable number still belonged to an account with ordinary login credentials and contacts.
Calling all short UINs valuable would go further than the evidence. The documented point is that some users treated short or patterned account numbers as desirable possessions. Client manuals explain the underlying identity system; contemporary reporting shows what people subsequently made of it.