Remembering is another measurement
The peak-end rule describes a pattern in retrospective evaluation. When people later judge an episode, its most intense part and its ending can carry considerable weight. The judgment is not necessarily a time-weighted total of everything that happened. Calling it a rule does not mean it predicts every memory or makes the middle disappear.
The distinction is between experience as it unfolds and an evaluation made afterwards. A difficult game can contain long ordinary stretches, a severe setback and a comfortable finish. A later overall rating is a different observation from the feelings recorded throughout that session. Applying the rule to that game is an illustration, not a result established by the medical studies below.
Pain recorded during and after treatment
Redelmeier and Kahneman recorded pain during colonoscopy and lithotripsy, then asked patients to evaluate the procedures afterwards. The later judgments were strongly related to the worst pain and to pain near the end. Longer procedures were not necessarily remembered as more unpleasant, despite the extra time involved.
This observational finding helped distinguish duration from remembered intensity. It did not show that duration never matters, nor that the two selected moments are the only things patients remember. It described how particular ratings related to a recorded course of pain.
A later randomized trial tested an intervention in colonoscopy. For some patients, a short interval was added at the end while the instrument’s tip remained in place. The extended group experienced a less painful ending and subsequently gave the whole procedure less unpleasant ratings. More elapsed time had not produced a worse retrospective evaluation.
What to take from the result
The contrast explains why researchers distinguish total discomfort from remembered discomfort. Improving an ending can change a later evaluation without removing the earlier discomfort. An improved rating does not make additional pain beneficial, and these results are not a recommendation to prolong medical treatment.
For games and other everyday activities, the cautious implication is that a final impression may deserve attention when interpreting an overall rating. It is still necessary to measure the experience itself. A pleasant final screen cannot establish that a frustrating session was comfortable throughout, just as a later memory is not a complete log of everything that preceded it.